There’s a particular kind of uncertainty that can come with leading someone who has been working longer than you have. You respect their experience. You know they’ve seen things you haven’t. And you want to do a good job, both in your role and for the people counting on you.
I’ve talked with younger managers who feel that tension. How do you earn trust? How do you make decisions when someone on your team has years of experience you’re still building? Those are understandable questions. But I’ve also met plenty of people in their 50s and beyond who are perfectly happy to have a younger manager. They like their work and their role. They know that being in charge comes with responsibilities and headaches they don’t particularly want. If someone else is eager and willing to take that on, they’re glad to have them.
I feel that way sometimes on volunteer committees. When someone younger than I am takes the lead, I remember how much I appreciated those opportunities when I was younger. I want to be a good team player and help them succeed. Having more experience doesn’t mean I want their job.
So if you’re a younger manager, give people a chance to support you before assuming they’ll resent you. An experienced employee who is comfortable in their role can be a tremendous resource. They may know the organization’s history, understand its relationships, and have seen several different approaches to the challenges you’re facing.
How you draw on that experience matters. Coming in determined to prove that you’re in charge can create friction that wasn’t there before. If you dismiss what people know or act as though nothing useful happened before you arrived, you’re giving them a reason to question your leadership.
There’s room to be confident and curious at the same time. You were selected to lead, and making decisions is part of your responsibility. You can take that responsibility seriously while asking someone, “You’ve seen other leaders handle situations like this. What worked well?” Or, “Is there something I might be overlooking?”
Then listen to the answer. Take notes. Give the person’s perspective real consideration. You won’t use every suggestion, but people can usually tell whether you wanted their input or were simply going through the motions. Asking and then immediately explaining why their idea won’t work doesn’t do much to build trust.
You also don’t need to ask for reassurance about every decision. There’s a difference between seeking useful perspective and repeatedly asking someone else to tell you what to do. Be specific about the input you need, consider it, and make the decision. When their advice helps, let them know.
The impression you want to create is that you’re doing a good job, and part of the reason is that you know when to ask for input. Over time, clear expectations, thoughtful decisions, and respect for people’s experience give them good reasons to trust you. You don’t have to settle the question of your age before you can begin doing those things.
Lead with confidence and curiosity
If you’re helping newer managers build productive relationships with their teams, we’d welcome a conversation about the situations they’re navigating and the support that would be useful. Contact us to explore leadership development for your organization.
